Tuesday, December 12, 2006

Attitude Check

Sometimes when I share with friends about my struggles with my boys, I half jokingly say that when my boys sin, they sin boldly. Their transgressions are very obvious. I often shake my head in disbelief that their sins are so blatant. Right after I tell them not to touch a certain object, they touch it, and that is with them looking at me in the eyes. My more conniving side of me comes out and thinks, “Why would they sin so blatant right in front of me, knowing that they will get disciplined for their actions? Don’t they want to be less obvious?” I, of course, shake my head in disbelief once again. My husband then reminds me that he would rather have them sin boldly than to sin in secrecy. It is easier to discipline boys because their sins are usually more obvious and in-your-face. They are simple creatures. This is, I’m told, different from girls in general who are more secretive. They rebel differently and can get away with more because it is not as easy to catch attitude issues. This is not to say that my boys don’t have attitude problems. In fact, this is one of the areas that we’re currently working on with our oldest.

It is easy to discipline for obvious disobedience such as not obeying when told to do a certain thing but didn’t. What if the child obeys outwardly but his body language tells you otherwise? What about whining? What about having a sour face? To me these are more serious because they convey what is in the heart. If the parents aren’t vigilant, the children can get away with such sins and will eventually fester to more problems. We are actively communicating with our children that attitudes are important. When we require them to obey, we mean to obey cheerfully. Even though they are outwardly obedient, inwardly they are not. Matthew 23:25-26 comes to mind:

“Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! For you clean the outside of the cup and the plate, but inside they are full of greed and self-indulgence. You blind Pharisee! First clean the inside of the cup and the plate, that the outside also may be clean.”

Jesus rebuked the Pharisees for what was in their hearts even though outwardly they were exemplary people worthy of respect and honor. Outward behavior is not always indicative of the heart, but the heart is most indicative of who we truly are.  Thus, we must first address what is in the heart in order to be truly clean on the outside. This is why it is important for us to discipline our children for attitude problems. I know that as they get older, they will become smarter and figure out how they can disobey without getting caught. Parenting will inevitably become more challenging. However, if we are diligent in disciplining even for the slightest remark or attitude problem while they are young, we will have a greater influence in their lives and help guide them through the more turbulent years.

1 Comment so far
Leave a comment

Lois, I absolutely agree with your conclusions in this entry. May I share some perspectives on the boy/girl issue from an anthropological standpoint since I can’t speak (yet) from the perspective of a parent training her child.

As you’ve noted, boys and girls are different and they have different tendencies in their expression and exercise of sin. But, part of your amazement and dismay at the boldness of your boys is rooted in the way you (as a woman and a Chinese-American) value indirection and harmony in relationships. I don’t want to distract from your main point that sin is rooted in the heart even though girls and boys have different tendencies. I only want to point out that girls’ tendency towards “secret” sin may be the result of their orientation towards group harmony and indirection. This is why a girl will rarely say “I don’t like you” to another girl, she will avoid or ignore the girl. A boy, on the other hand, might be perfectly willing to say “I don’t like you” quite clearly to someone he doesn’t like. Obviously, both situations are sinful and unloving. Similarly,when a parent issues a directive the rebellious girl might conveniently “not hear” or roll her eyes at the command while the boy might look the parent in the eye and say outright “No, I’m not doing that.” As women, we find the boy’s response audacious. As Westerners, we find the girl’s indirection insidious. As Asians, we find the boy’s boldness offensive and arrogant. As believers, we see clearly the ugliness of sin.

So, what does it take to train the heart of a little girl? My guess is observant parents! I agree with you that they can get away with more if the parent is not observant. But, I don’t think it’s because they’re trying any harder than a boy to get away with sin. Little boys and little girls can be equally deceptive. Yet, it’s wise to be aware that some little girls are wired physiologically and culturally in a way that can let them “fly under the radar” undetected.


Leave a comment

HTML allowed:<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

(required)

(required, never shared)


Before you post, please prove you are sentient.

What is 7 * 3?